Board Member Roles and Responsibilities
A comprehensive guide to understanding the governance, fiduciary duties, and essential responsibilities of nonprofit board members.
What is Governance?
Direction
Governance is the system for directing and controlling an organization, encompassing structures, processes, and rules for decision-making, power distribution, and accountability. For nonprofits, the board provides direction (strategic leadership, mission guidance) and control (oversight, accountability).
Control
Effective nonprofit governance advances the mission and upholds organizational principles. Crucially, governance differs from management: the board governs high-level policy and performance monitoring, while management handles daily operations.
Accountability
This system ensures accountability to stakeholders (donors, clients, public) and compliance with legal and ethical standards.
Why Boards Exist
Stewards of Public Trust
Nonprofit boards act as stewards of the public trust, ensuring mission fidelity and responsible resource use. As nonprofits lack owners, the board represents the public and the mission itself.
Legal Requirement
Boards are legally required for incorporated nonprofits, providing the structure for accountability. For example, tax-exempt charities in the U.S. (501(c)(3)) and registered charities in Canada require boards to ensure resources serve charitable purposes, preventing private gain.
Credibility
This oversight provides credibility to donors and regulators. In essence, boards exist to deliver oversight, accountability, and strategic direction as fiduciaries for the community and stakeholders.
Fiduciary Duty
Duty of Obedience
Ensure compliance with laws, regulations, bylaws, and mission
Duty of Loyalty
Prioritize nonprofit's interests above personal gain
Duty of Care
Act as a reasonably prudent person would
Board service involves serious legal fiduciary duties: Care, Loyalty, and Obedience, binding directors to always act in the nonprofit's best interest.
Board members are trustees of the organization's assets, held to high standards of good faith, honesty, and loyalty. Fulfilling these duties protects the organization's reputation and assets, maintains trust, and avoids potential personal liability (e.g., for unpaid taxes in Canada). Understanding this fiduciary role is crucial for sound, ethical governance.
The Governance System
Bylaws & Policies
Defining board powers and organizational structure
Roles & Responsibilities
Clear division between board and management
Reporting Mechanisms
Financial reports, program data, and audits
Checks & Balances
System ensuring accountability and oversight
A nonprofit's governance system is the framework of policies, processes, and roles ensuring effective direction and control, anchored by the board working with management and stakeholders. This framework creates checks and balances, functioning as the "operating manual" for how the board, management, and stakeholders interact.
Direction and Control
Foresight
Strategic vision and planning
Oversight
Monitoring health and compliance
Insight
Leveraging expertise and wisdom
A board's purpose can be summarized as providing "direction" and "control." Direction involves setting mission, vision, and strategy. Control involves monitoring performance, ensuring compliance, and safeguarding resources. The board balances both: setting strategic goals (direction) while implementing oversight mechanisms like financial controls and risk assessment (control). This is often described as providing foresight (strategic vision), oversight (monitoring health and compliance), and insight (leveraging expertise) – maintaining a high-level perspective to navigate effectively while ensuring accountability.
Core Roles of Board Members
Mission & Purpose
Define, protect, and periodically review the mission.
Executive Director
Select, support, evaluate, and set compensation for the ED.
Strategic Planning
Participate in setting organizational direction and goals.
Financial Oversight
Approve budgets, review financials, ensure controls, safeguard assets.
Resource Development
Help ensure adequate resources (funding, support) for the mission.
Policy & Risk Management
Establish key policies and oversee risk mitigation.
Program Oversight
Monitor program effectiveness and mission alignment.
Board Self-Management
Recruit, orient, and evaluate the board itself; plan for succession.
Community Relations & Advocacy
Serve as ambassadors, building public standing and advocating for the cause.
Secondary Roles and Committee Structure
Secondary Roles
Beyond core governance, board members often undertake secondary, more operational support roles based on organizational needs and personal skills:
- Volunteering: Hands-on help in programs or events (especially in smaller nonprofits).
- Fundraising Activities: Direct involvement in soliciting donations, thanking donors, or event support.
- Advisory Expertise: Lending professional skills (legal, marketing, finance) to assist management.
- Operational Committee Work: Participating in committees focused on specific tasks (e.g., event planning).
- Specific Advocacy: Engaging in targeted public speaking or sector advocacy.
It's vital for members to distinguish between their governance hat and these supportive roles. While core roles are non-negotiable legal responsibilities focused on governance, secondary roles leverage passion and skills to further aid operations and outreach.
Committee Types
Boards often use committees to manage workload effectively. Committees fall into two main types:
- Governance Committees: Handle board-level oversight, typically composed of board members only (e.g., Executive, Finance/Audit, Governance/Nominating, ED Compensation). They recommend actions to the full board.
- Operational (Advisory) Committees: Focus on specific program or operational areas, often including staff or external experts (e.g., Program Advisory, Event Planning, Marketing). They typically advise or support staff, reporting through management or providing informational updates to the board.
Committees require clear mandates (terms of reference). Governance committees report to the board; operational committees usually report to staff/ED. Smaller organizations should avoid too many committees; streamlined models (like a three-committee structure: Governance, Internal Affairs, External Affairs) can improve efficiency. Crucially, committees support the board's work; the full board retains ultimate accountability for governance decisions. Well-structured committees enhance board effectiveness and organizational support.
Nonprofit Board Governance Guide
This comprehensive guide breaks down nonprofit governance into eight essential sections.
Whether you're new to board service or a seasoned leader, you'll find valuable insights.
Ditch the Email Chaos. Manage Your Nonprofit Board the Smart Way.
Tired of scattered documents, endless email threads, and tracking down votes? Quorum brings everything your board needs into one secure, affordable platform.
Lost Files?
Centralized dashboard with secure AWS S3 document storage keeps everything organized.
Meeting Mayhem?
Integrated agendas, notes and decision logging with rich text editing.
Voting Hassles?
Secure online voting with anonymous options, receipts and easy tracking.
Just $20/Board/Month with unlimited members included. No per-user fees.